‍TL;DR
If you are picking ad budgets by feel and discounting because “it’s Q4,” you are leaving profitability to chance. Tie revenue, ad performance, and all expenses into one model. Optimize toward a clear net profit goal. Use the right ROAS targets, which change as spend changes, and never run discounts without knowing the required performance lift to stay at breakeven or better.

Why “Great ROAS” Can Still Lose Money

Most tools live on one side of your business.

• MarTech: Shopify, Meta, Klaviyo. Great at revenue and channel metrics.
• FinTech: QuickBooks, Finaloop, Xero. Great at expenses.

They rarely overlap. Profit lives where they meet.

Key concept
Contribution Profit (CP) = Revenue − (COGS + shipping and fulfillment + payment fees + platform fees + ad spend)
Net Profit = Contribution Profit − Fixed and Operating Expenses (OpEx)

You do not keep the business alive with ROAS alone. You do it with contribution dollars that cover OpEx, then create true net profit.

If CP is less than monthly OpEx, you are unprofitable, no matter how “good” ROAS looks.

The Ad Budget Mistake Under $20M ARR

Operators naturally treat ad budget as risky and keep it “safe.” But underspending can make it mathematically impossible to hit breakeven or a profit goal. We see brands with an “8x ROAS” still losing money because they are not generating enough contribution dollars to pay overhead.

Better question

Given our OpEx and margin structure, how much should we spend, and at what performance, to hit our net profit goal?

That is a solvable math problem.

The Counterintuitive Truth About ROAS Targets as Spend Scales

Two realities are true at once.

1. As you increase spend, performance such as ROAS often declines because of auction pressure and saturation.
2. As you increase spend, the required ROAS to hit the same net profit goal often decreases because you create more contribution dollars to cover OpEx.

In practice, your required ROAS versus spend often follows a negative log curve. Think of an upside-down hockey stick. These example values are purely illustrative:

• $10k per month spend → required ROAS roughly 2.5 to 3.5 to reach breakeven
• $30k per month → required ROAS roughly 2.2 to 2.8
• $50k per month → required ROAS roughly 2.0 to 2.5

Your exact curve depends on variable margin, AOV, COGS structure, and OpEx (this lives in your P&L)

Discounts: The Silent Profit Killer (Unless You Correctly Model it First)

Discounts compress variable margin and spike the required performance.

Example
Baseline variable margin before paid media: 70%

• Breakeven required ROAS is about 3.3

Run a 20% off promo with all other costs unchanged.

• Breakeven required ROAS might jump to 10

If you cannot realistically reach that during a promo window, the sale will lose money even if topline and 8.2 ROAS looks great.

Rule
Never turn on a discount without knowing the required ROAS for that discount and monitoring it in flight.

Three Efficiency Ratios That Predict Profit

1. Profit efficiency = Net Profit divided by Revenue
2. Variable efficiency = Contribution margin percent after ad spend
3. Fixed expense efficiency = OpEx divided by Revenue

Lower OpEx relative to revenue can be the fastest path to profit. Every dollar removed from OpEx flows directly to Net Profit. To add that same dollar via sales, you might need ten dollars in new revenue at a 10% contribution margin.

A Simple Workflow You Can Run Weekly, and Daily in Q4

1. Set a profit goal
   Breakeven, 10% net, 15% net. Choose what matches your phase.
2. Ingest all costs
   COGS, shipping, payments, platform fees, ad spend, payroll, rent, software, insurance.
3. Calculate required ROAS by spend
   Generate a curve. At spend X, we need ROAS at least Y to hit our goal.
4. Stress-test scenarios
   • Discounts: 10%, 20%, BOGO. How does required ROAS change?
   • Team changes: add a hire and see the shift in required performance.
   • AOV and CVR lifts: estimate how much headroom you gain.
5. Deploy with guardrails
   Monitor daily. Are we above required ROAS at today’s spend?
   If not, adjust budgets or end underperforming promos.
6. Exploit the easy lever
   Review OpEx monthly. Eliminate tools and overhead that do not move revenue or margin. Those savings go straight to profit.

Black Friday and Cyber Monday Without Margin Regret

• Model first, not after. Know required ROAS for each promo before it launches.
• Prefer AOV-friendly offers such as thresholds and bundles. These protect contribution margin better than broad percent-off sitewide.
• Map discounts to margin reality. Favor SKUs with healthier margin or inventory that must be cleared.
• Budget to the math. Scale only while you are at or above the required ROAS guardrail for your goal.
• Plan for December and January. Protect cash so you are not stranded with high OpEx and no contribution cushion.

Quick Math Mini-Guide

Inputs per month

• OpEx (fixed): payroll, rent, software, insurance
• COGS percent, shipping percent, payment percent, platform percent
• AOV
• Target ad spend
• Discount percent if any

Steps

1. Gross margin before ads = 1 − (COGS% + shipping% + payment% + platform%)
2. Adjust for discount by reducing AOV or margin accordingly
3. Contribution per revenue dollar before ads = adjusted gross margin
4. Required ROAS at a target spend
   • Let revenue be R and ad spend be S
   • CP = (R × adjusted margin) − S
   • Net profit goal G implies CP must be at least OpEx + G × R
   • Solve for R divided by S to find the ROAS that satisfies the condition at the given S

You can build this in a spreadsheet or use Pentane to do it instantly with guardrails and sliders.

What Changes With AI

At BottleKeeper we ran extraordinarily lean, six people through acquisition and sixty million dollars of cumulative sales. We did it with math, systems, and simple operations. Today, AI lets you:

• Auto-resolve most customer service tickets at level one
• Multiply creative versioning and testing velocity
• Use ops agents to move data across tools without manual effort

Important point. AI multiplies whatever system you point it at. If the system ignores expenses, AI will scale unprofitable decisions faster. Build the profit model first. Then let AI accelerate execution.

Operating Principles I Learned the Hard Way

• Family first and time is finite. Every yes takes time from your kids. Make it count.
• Small teams and big systems. Automate before you hire. Hire only for compounding work.
• Math, not vibes. Your gut sets hypotheses. The model sets budgets.
• Train for hard things. Physical resilience makes business turbulence easier.

A Practical BFCM Checklist

• Profit goal set
• Variable and fixed expenses fully mapped
• Required ROAS curve generated for multiple spend levels
• Each discount has a modeled required ROAS and a kill switch
• AOV and CVR plan to offset discount drag
• Daily guardrails that alert when actual ROAS falls below required ROAS
• OpEx trim list for December and January

Who Pentane Is For

eComm first brands that are spending on ads and want clear, prescriptive guidance, not just another dashboard. Pentane ingests accounting, ad spend, and revenue data, applies straightforward math, and tells you exactly how to adjust ad budgets, discounts, and expenses to hit your net profit goal. The 15 minute onboarding guides unrealistic targets toward reality. Let us show you how.

‍